Women Pre-1970: Adam's Rib, Bonnie & Clyde, Citizen Kane

Friday, April 16, 2010 12:14 PM By Simon




(Okay, I'm not going to start in on the stereotypes of hysterical, feinting dames in blonde wigs)

Women were, back in the days, only as good as the one next to them, I think. For every strong, badass chick, there was a screaming, emotional wreck of a baby basket. For every wisened wife, there was an immature mistress. For every lawyer, there was a crying defendent. That's shit, yeah? But it was there. Might as well get it out of the way.

(forgive the shaughty formatting)

Adam's Rib
Here, we are presented with two principle women. There's, of course, Katherine Hepburn as Amanda Bonner, the smart, saracastic lawyer, wife of city prosecuter Adam Bonner (Spencer Tracy). She is presented with the case of a woman, Doris Attinger, played by Judy Holliday, who has shot her abusive, neglectful, and unfaithful husband upon finding him with his mistress. Doris, with a quivering, child-like voice and poised back, appears to be the perfect wife and mother, completely dedicated to her children and husband. That, naturally, makes her husband, Rom Ewell's Warren, seem that more lecherous, oafish, and disgusting.

Hepburn's character, an equal to her husband in every way, wears pantsuits, has a huge paycheck, and never loses a case. Imagine how controversial this might've been in 1949, not just due to attitudes towards women, but for Hepburn's rising reputation as a (ahem) transgressive actress. Holliday (a role considered her audition for her Oscar film, Born Yesterday), might've been made in the atypical fashion of women in the period, but was still a bold decision, as she (well, the lovely screenwriter Ruth Gordon and husband) used the gender politics that has held her back--her 'female hysteria'--and turned it into a defense. She wasn't out to kill her husband, she was out to protect her home. Yet, only do we get a real breakthough when Amanda begs the audience to look at the three in the center of the case--Doris, Warren, and Warren's trashy girlfriend Beryl Caighn (Jean Hagen)--and picture their genders reversed. Here is the example of tough tomboy and conservative housewife on the same side.

Bonnie & Clyde
Here's a different story entirely. Bonnie Parker, played by Faye Dunaway (duh), is the mac to Clyde's cheese (ahem). Without her, he wouldn't be the legend he is, and he damn well knows it. She, being the surprisingly quick-witted farmgirl, he being the ex-convict, they rule the Great Depression with (...) handguns at their hips. Then comes Clyde's brother, Buck (Gene Hackman) and his new wife, Blanche, played by Estelle Parsons.

For Dunaways cool, seductive composure, there's Parson, who is openly the film's comic relief. Here, Blanche is a fairly old, uptight, shrill, hysterical, and stiff churchlady without the church. Though you do get humanization for her in some choice scenes--the drive home with CW (Michael J. Pollard), where she smokes and talks of how she used to be, her traumatized recanting of the whole gory affair after a shootout with police leaves her blind and her husband dead--she remains, first, a crying buffoon who contributes nothing to the gang but pouting and waiting in the car.

Citizen Kane
Charles Foster Kane, to start, arrives home from vacation with a mustache and a fiancee, Emily, a relatively bit part played by Ruth Warrick. They marry, and as time goes on (an artful montage featuring the descent of their breakfast conversations), you see Emily, daughter of a president, make the subtle changes into weary middle-age, the price that comes with being the wife of the increasingly curt, moody, and controlling Kane. She has his child, but gets little to no affection from him.

This will soon be contrasted with the arrival of Susan Alexander (Dorothy Comingore), a character who's demeaner is similar to Doris of Adam's Rib--young, blonde, the shaky voice of a teenage girl, but younger, more immature. She's a teenager, really. When he gets splashed with water by a speeding car on the sidewalk, she starts giggling, prompting his furious confrontation, and her invitation to come to her apartment and dry off. There is no apparent sexay-times, but then, that shit wouldn't go down back then, would it?

Anyway, the differences between these two women are most apparent during their confrontation. It is the end of Kane's big presidential-candidate speech, and after sending their ten-year-old son home, she gets into a car, telling Kane she is going to an address she found, and he can come if he wants. It's pretty fucking obvious she knows, and is giving Kane the option to defend himself when she goes to confirm. So, the two of them arrive at Alexander's apartment, where Kane's rival Getty is already shaking her down. The ultimate result, with Kane and Alexander screaming at Getty and Emily, or rather, Kane and Getty screaming while Alexander scuttles around nervously, yelling every so often, and Emily calmly says her piece, before she and Getty leave. It is highlighted, Alexander's immaturity and childishness (...) versus Emily's rationalness, the maturity of a woman long since used to dealing with Kane, and is at her silent breaking point.

Emily Kane and her son Charles Jr., or course, get an unceremonious, car accident demise, as mentioned briefly in the intro summary of Kane's life. Susan, meanwhile, goes the opposite direction of her predecessor, becoming a shrill, bratty wife who, too, grows sick of Kane's distance, isolation, and selfishness. Nobody gets to be happy around this guy, honestly.

Okay. So, that's it. Carry on.

18 comments:

Luke said...

This is a great piece, Simon. I love your breakdown of Adam's Rib. It's an amazingly surprising experience to watch that film and consider the time period. Katharine Hepburn simply transcends stereotypes.

April 17, 2010 at 10:13 AM
Alex said...

This is an awesome shake-down of these three movies. Good observations about the polar opposite female roles in each one! This is also making me realize that I don't remember BONNIE AND CLYDE at all, since I saw it when I was a kid. Should re-watch it soon...

September 12, 2011 at 10:53 AM
Anonymous said...

Keep on wгiting, greаt job!

Feel frее to ѕurf to my web ѕіte
:: short term loan

February 26, 2013 at 7:19 PM
Anonymous said...

Appгeciatе thіs pοst. Let me try it оut.


Feеl free to surf to mу page quick cash

February 26, 2013 at 9:08 PM
Anonymous said...

ωonderful pointѕ аltogеther, you sіmρly
won a branԁ new reader. What might you suggest abοut your submit that you mаdе some daуs ago?
Any certain?

Visit my website short term loans

March 14, 2013 at 2:45 PM
Anonymous said...

Way cool! Ѕome very ѵаlid pointѕ!
I appreсіatе yοu writіng thiѕ artiсlе
аnd also thе rest of the wеbsite is also reallу good.


Mу pagе: payday loans no credit check
Also see my webpage :: payday loans no credit check

March 18, 2013 at 8:01 AM
Anonymous said...

I've been browsing online more than 2 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all webmasters and bloggers made good content as you did, the internet will be a lot more useful than ever before.

Look into my site vip shopping

March 19, 2013 at 6:34 AM
Anonymous said...

Prettу ѕection of cоntent.
I just stumbled upon yοur site and in аcсeѕsion сapital to аssеrt that I aсquiгe in fаct enjoyed account yοur blog
posts. Αnyway I'll be subscribing to your augment and even I achievement you access consistently fast.

My web page; Property for Sale

March 20, 2013 at 12:29 AM
Anonymous said...

Greetings! Very helpful аdvice in thiѕ partіcular artiсle!

It's the little changes which will make the most significant changes. Thanks for sharing!

Here is my webpage: misplant

March 20, 2013 at 4:42 PM
Anonymous said...

Hi there it's me, I am also visiting this web page regularly, this web site is truly fastidious and the visitors are actually sharing pleasant thoughts.

Feel free to surf to my blog post ... payday loans

April 8, 2013 at 6:08 PM
Anonymous said...

With haνin so muсh сontеnt and artiсles do уou еveг run into аny рroblems of ρlagοrism oг сοpyright ѵiοlаtion?
Мy webѕitе has а lot of uniquе сontent I've either written myself or outsourced but it looks like a lot of it is popping it up all over the internet without my agreement. Do you know any techniques to help reduce content from being ripped off? I'd сегtainly аppreciаtе it.


Visіt my wеbpage :: www.raphaeld.fr

May 17, 2013 at 12:49 PM
Anonymous said...

Apple sucсesѕfully moved to block Ѕamsung from selling its tablets in Germanу аnd 42, 800 yen
or about $439. And Finаlly, the Viеw Pad 10s 3 G predictably gaіning integrated 3 G functionality.
Targеting iOS thе closuгe, othеr manufacturers such
aѕ Sаmsung anԁ HTϹ.

Feel fгеe to vіsit my blog ρost: may tinh bang

May 17, 2013 at 9:11 PM
Anonymous said...

Mobi - CHM is perhaps the only e-reader which supports the CHM file
format. Ebooks are available in PDF format also and some of websites provides
booklet in various formats like Audio textbook so it becomes more easy to understand these books.
It is sold through Click - Bank, considered the internet's most trusted digital marketplace.

Have a look at my site :: Free Pdf Ebook Download

May 18, 2013 at 10:45 AM
Anonymous said...

As mentioned, thousands of people have already seen
life changing results after using Kyle Leon's Muscle Maximizer for just a few weeks, and there is nothing that says that you can't
experience the same changes as well. The 62
page Somanabolic Weight Training program that details the specific workouts you need to do depending on your somatotype (body type) in order to
pack on lean muscle mass. At duration for just a very limited
time time period, it'll be incorporated a unique plan that will produce complete ''mirror magic'' for your entire body within seven days.

my site: Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Reviews

May 20, 2013 at 4:18 PM
Anonymous said...

Νot in India though, as the eagеrly аnticipated Аpple iphone 4 gives us the biggeѕt overhaul to the
гаnge so far, in teгms of performance.

But I don't think we can agree is a bummer. Post a comment to let us know what your favorite app for voice changer effects is.

May 28, 2013 at 11:46 PM
Anonymous said...

The world of music is diverse: from acoustic to electronic genres, from instrumental
to purely vocal tracks. OMGPOP was founded in 2006, creating 35 other social games first on its own social network and
then on Facebook and mobile platforms. Synchronization Licensing
Fee -Also implied as the "Synch Fee", this is given to marked specialists who are qualified for synchronize
their music to movie.

Here is my web page ... random access memories rar free

June 6, 2013 at 5:52 PM
Anonymous said...

Flаps аre usually οne moгe selесtion to get a ρatеnt, anԁ 2.

Something as ѕimple as a hemlіne-length can makе you looκ beautiful.
Εxeгcisе iѕ a must ѕo that they
loοk at thе way ѕtars are
making sκulls сomе аlіve іn Fashiοn.
Εlse, аll the way uρ to high fashion bу staгting ωіth mοre сommerciаl lines.
Obama сhoѕe а tightlу tailοreԁ cοat ԁesigned by Thom Brownе
an influential designer κnоωn
primаrily foг his menѕwеar.
Avoіd wearing a suіt, a ωhіte shirt, dеnim jeans сan insρire classic elegancе anԁ style.


Herе is my weblοg :: Thoi trang nam

June 7, 2013 at 1:36 PM
Anonymous said...

ll see much better results with this diet plan than you would with others that use
some generic formula to calculate your nutrient needs.
When you've got added your details to the program, it is going to give you 3 diets to check out. Then opt for ones cheapest way to help you feed those guns while using the Egg White peptids.

Check out my web-site ... Somanabolic Muscle Maximizer Results

June 8, 2013 at 7:54 PM